Get the Monday email →
Loading player…

Prediction Markets—as Infrastructure? | DC Fintech Week 2026

DC Fintech WeekMon, Nov 2, 2026, 12:00 AM

Prediction markets are becoming more than places to bet on outcomes; they are becoming inputs into how institutions and the wider economy measure probability, price risk, and make decisions. What happens when regulated firms begin to depend on those signals? This panel examines whether prediction markets are becoming part of the financial system's information infrastructure and, if so, what standards of integrity, reliability, and oversight should come with that role. • Moderator: Gabe Rosenberg, Partner, Davis Polk & Wardwell LLP • JB Mackenzie, Vice President and General Manager, Futures and Prediction Markets, Robinhood Markets, Inc. • Brian Quintenz, Director, Kalshi • CJ Hetherington, Chief Executive Officer & Co-Founder, Limitless Labs • Douglas Friedman, Chief Legal Officer, Tradeweb • Yesha Yadav, Professor of Law, Associate Dean, Vanderbilt University Law School

Transcript

Back to part two of an action-packed DC Fintech Week. Um We already had our conversation with Tarik about prediction markets. And prediction markets are perhaps one of the hottest topics in the news nowadays. It is a great pleasure to broaden the conversation and to talk about prediction markets not just in terms of the regulation but as infrastructure. This is a conversation that I started actually with one of the panelists a while back because I'm interested in that public goods question.

What kinds of data can actually be generated from prediction markets, good or bad? What is the utility of that information? And what happens when Wall Street, when critical infrastructure banks, financial agencies, and others use data and prediction market data for their operations. So with this we have an all-star panel from Robinhood, Kalshi, Vanderbilt, as well as Tradeweb. And I'd like to welcome them to the stage.

Thank you.

So hi everyone. My name is Gabe Rosenberg. I'm a partner in the financial institutions group at Davis Polk. And as Chris said, we're going to talk about prediction markets from a little bit of a different angle. As the promise of prediction markets, Tarik was talking about this a little bit earlier today, lies in part in the data collecting, the the herd, the information all coming together.

And as these prediction markets mature, the question is who's going to use that data? What will it be useful for? Um and to talk about that we have as Chris mentioned an all-star panel. Let me let them just each briefly uh introduce themselves and then we'll get started.

Great. Uh good afternoon everyone. Thank you so much to the Fintech Foundation, to Chris, to the crew for bringing us all together. Uh my name is Yesha Yadav. I'm professor of law and associate dean at Vanderbilt Law School and a board member here at the Fintech Foundation.

Uh good afternoon. My name is Bryan Quintenz. I was a former commissioner of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and am a board member of the Kalshi Exchange.

Good afternoon. Doug Friedman from Tradeweb and I'm our chief legal officer.

Hello everyone. Thanks a lot for spending your time with us today. I'm CJ. I'm the CEO and co-founder at a company called Limitless Labs. Um we're also standing up a US-regulated exchange called Limitless Markets US.

Thank you.

Good afternoon everybody. I'm JB McKenzie. I'm the general manager of the futures and predictions offering at Robinhood. Um where we started offering this product a little over uh 2 and 1/2 years ago.

Great. So Doug, Bryan, let's start with you. Um can you set the stage a little bit? I mentioned the use of data from prediction markets. What are banks, insurers, asset managers, what are people really doing with event contract data right now as we speak?

Yeah. I'll I'll start.

[laughter]

Um thank you uh for the question, Gabe, and great to be here. And I Tradeweb and Kalshi actually uh did a partnership and we did an investment in February that we announced and we went live with the Kalshi data on our platform in June. And what we have found is that the predictive prediction markets and the event contracts that it is a uh a signal and a an important data source for our institutional clients. And what they're doing is they're weighing that against what they already have for macro environment information and they're managing making investment decisions and managing risk associated with those event details. And what we went up doing was taking about 10,000 of the Kalshi contracts and about a third of them are relevant for our markets, really you know, rates and credit and not sports.

But we have found that our our clients have really loved having access to this data side by side with their with the pricing and market data that we have on our system and we've had an incredible response from our clients to as they factor that in to make their investment decisions and manage risk. And so it's been it's been a terrific partnership and we think it's become a real data point for our investment group.

Yeah, I I appreciate that. I mean I think you know, there there are a couple of interesting aspects that have just started to emerge and grow with um how much Kalshi has evolved over the last year. I think the two primary things are that institutions are now moving away from just watching these markets to participating in them to looking at them for price discovery and actually hedging risk or helping their clients to hedge risk. The second is that liquidity is no longer a problem. In markets liquidity is the biggest issue and now that we have a critical mass of market participants we are accepting um suggested markets that can meet a discrete end users need and because of how many market participants there are on the platform now they can actively contribute to finding price discovery around that discrete event, helping someone price it, and then allowing someone the liquidity to hedge it.

And an example of that, there are a number of examples across the board, but there was a um a movie theater chain that wanted to hedge how many wide wide released movies would be offered in Q4. That's a pretty discrete marketplace for what we would think of as a derivative it's offering, yet Kalshi took that suggestion, offered that market, got participants to price it, and allowed that movie theater chain to hedge that risk. Right? are hedging their weather-related risk. There's an ice cream store that's hedging how hot or cool the weather will be.

If you think of an ice cream store, they probably make 70 to 80% of their their money during the summer months. Most of that's probably on the weekends. If you have a cool spell over a weekend, that could mean a big difference to a small business's bottom line. You have a bike tour company in New York and a different one in California that are hedging whether or not it's going to rain because they know that their sales are going to go down. You have um uh uh people exposed to energy rates hedging how hot or cool it will get in certain cities.

Um we have Cantor, ClearStreet, Marex that are now building out institutional pipes. And we have City that has transitioned from looking at this data to making sure that these probabilities are placed directly in front of their advisors. So, in my view, it's the mainstream.

Yeah, I'll tell you I I love the goatherder story. Um cuz to me that's something that just can't be hedged otherwise. A lot of these can't be hedged otherwise, but just to think about people can have relative idiosyncratic risks, and they can be done and priced and people can hedge that way.

Well, we didn't even talk about I mean the reinsurance aspect of this is huge. And you think about what insurance is used for, it's used for a lot of these different discrete prices and people don't think of that as the same way they think of this market activity that they're struggling to identify or put into a box, but insurance companies are now hedging um insurance products they're offering to sports teams using Kalshi's marketplace as a reinsurance vehicle. I mean this is this is uh new and very fascinating territory that's um uh widening the aperture for risk management tools for institutions.

So Yasha, let's let's turn to you. Um I know you've thought a lot about these markets, what people need to know about how they work in order to be comfortable in their use. You know, there are probably very few industries more regulated than the banking industry. You guys spend a lot of time on If a bank were to use this information, let's say to inform the reserves it holds, um to inform its business, what do they really need to think about in terms of what they'd be comfortable with? What, you know, who might not want to touch this at all?

Yeah. Great question, Gabe. And you know, I think it's worth prefacing this question with just how consequential these markets are likely to be for the mainstream financial system as Brian and you know, as just outlined. So, for that to work, the mainstream financial system, our banking industries, our regulators need to be ultra confident in the quality of the information as well as in the production process that that information has been generated again. So, looking at this, you know, Gabe, and I know you do a bunch of this work, there are three characteristics to me at least that really stand out as being super important.

Now, first and foremost is this question of liquidity. Now, Brian mentioned it that these markets are becoming incredibly liquid here. Now, we've seen for example, uh Kalshi did, I think, reportedly like $22 billion worth of contracts just in a single week alone, a record-breaking week, right? So, huge amounts of volume coming up. The question is, is this liquidity going to be super resilient, right, in the event of certain stressful events?

Will the market makers that are engaged in providing markets to this uh to this uh into this space, will they remain on this market? Right? So, this liquidity has to be deep across the contracts that the banks, the insurers, and other funds are going to look at. In addition, is it going to be super resilient when it comes to the crunch? And liquidity providers are not going to disappear just when that pricing process needs to be ultra robust.

Now, this is not unique to prediction markets. This is This is something that's existed across the board, but given how important these markets are becoming and the case they're making for themselves, this liquidity production has to be ultra important. Number two, I think one of the most essential things is resolution integrity. What does that mean? That every single time we have a contract, that contract resolves against a trusted event.

That the people who say, "Look, I think this event's been triggered," that we can trust those people. That might be an oracle. So, you need the oracle to be super trusty. Um that might be some kind of adjudication committee. You need that committee to be robust.

And if if banks, insurance funds, and others are going to outsource their risk management to this information source, that adjudication process has to be ultra credible. Last thing, and I know we'll talk about it, is resistance to manipulation. Right? That is going to be across the board. You need the pricing process to be super resistant to manipulation.

Now, in futures markets, that tends to be relatively okay, as Brian and others know in this room. Underlying for oil, for gold, is pretty large relative to any single participant. But when you have a contract where it could be for example a single person that might be able to decide in some cases that is a that is a more problematic design. So we really need to think hard about about these following three features liquidity resolution integrity and making sure that manipulation and governance is on point.

Yeah, that's interesting. I mean we've seen this resolution integrity come up a number of times. I would say probably less consequential than than you're worried about but you know what someone perform in the Super Bowl, right? All these questions about want to make sure that the contract is very very well specified and that the resolution coming in is equally well specified and perfectly matched to those particular contracts. I I think that's really critical as institutions get more and more into the space and and start using the information.

JB let's go to you talking about that information and and how it's generated. So I think we're used to in tradfi for lack of a better term thinking about information and informed trading coming from institutions, right? And we were talking about this before generally retail trading and stocks is seen as not necessarily related to fundamentals of stocks really retail trading all over the place and in fact that's why a lot of institutions like trading with with retail participants. This is different, right? Prediction markets because it's in fact the wisdom of the crowd the wisdom of retail participants and others that's creating this data and informing this data.

So how do you think about that, right? Like is this retail flow providing information that's critical here? Is it information that can be trusted? How do you think about that this really I think very fundamental difference in where the information is generated from?

So I think part of what's evolved over time is the retail participant. So, going back to when I started trading, which was a very, very long time ago, it was 20 years plus, the data that you had to make a decision usually came off of, you know, an email or maybe a news story. What has happened is technology has completely altered that. And what technology has done is it's put real-time information into our hands. You know, my the Robinhood app is probably as powerful as Bloomberg's terminal when it comes to the ability to both access and distribute data.

I think what prediction markets have done is accelerate that even further. And what you're seeing, and we started to see this actually during the pandemic with some of the meme stocks such as um the Carnival Cruise Lines, the airlines, where the institutions were pushing that market down, but retail was coming underneath and and and lifting it back up. And so, you had this first sort of time where institutions and retail were fighting against each other. And I think what's happened with with prediction markets is you started to see the power of retail participation. People are incredibly well informed.

There are decisions that they're making to enter into the market, and I think prediction markets continue to help evolve that. And just look at the different types of products that are out there. Um you know, before it started off with the presidential election, and that called into questions the accuracy of the polls, cuz why? Polls are snapshots. Prediction markets are real-time.

But even as you continue to watch the evolution into other products, sports, or even more importantly, I'll say the financial sector, going into this the Fed rate cut here or the question in September, we saw a tremendous amount of of of uh participation from our retail traders because they had an opinion based upon all of the information they consumed, and they were very early to the market. And I think what you're seeing more and more is retail is now pushing the change where institutions were the ones before. So, if as a trader, you want to have information from your institutional information, you want to see your market information, but now you have retail information and that that gives you something that you never had before, which is a power of information to make a great decision, whatever that investment has been. I think what you've seen from a lot of the um prediction market participants is it's not just people trading, it's also looking at the data. I know a lot of people who actually just look at the data on our website or on our app to see the direction of where it's going and they may trade a different product, but it's an input from that.

So, I do think that what you're seeing more and more is that that retail data and and power of that information coming to the market is making it to Brian's point where now institutions need to plug in. Um it's almost a disservice to their traders if they're not doing that and I think that's only going to continue to grow globally.

Yeah, and I'll tell you. I mean, so I'm in the practice of law. Um I can't trade on Kalshi. I'm not allowed. Uh but I go all the time and look at the probabilities and you know, help my clients understand things based on those probabilities.

A big thing that was happening a couple months ago was the potential promise of crypto market structure legislation and I'd watch it on a daily basis and I'd talk to clients about it and why things were going up and things were going down. It just adds another level, I think, of um deep analysis into to what we're talking about here. Um CJ, let's let's turn to you for a second. So, you at Limitless, you run short duration markets. You resolve against an oracle.

Yeshua was talking about oracles and their role before. Um you filed I think you mentioned this as to become a regulated exchange in the United States. Te- tell us a bit about that application, what the regulated status give you. Why are you going through that process?

Sure. Um that's a great question. I think that people look at what we do outside of the US and they immediately assume that's what we're going to do in the United States. That's actually not the case at all. Um we pioneered short duration prices contracts for various different assets, whether we're talking about cryptocurrencies uh or commodities or even equities in the US or in Asia on our on-chain exchange.

Um and we you know, we launched these markets before even Polymarket and and Kalshi and they kind of became a really kind of cornerstone of the prediction market industry and represent a lot of the revenue today. But how we approach building and how we approach the market is never a finished product. It's always assumptions based. We try to spend as much time with the customer as we can and understand what their needs are. And we understood that when people were trading the what price is Bitcoin going to be at 4:00 p.

m. on Friday,

Yeah.

we understood that they wanted their money back faster. They wanted to trade more. And so the duration came, you know, shorter and shorter. 15 minutes is probably the the optimal duration for these kind of markets. And we actually see that they're bringing more valuable price signals to the market than perpetuals or options, which is super exciting and there's a lot of data to support that.

However, when we come to the US, we look at the market, we see everyone is fighting for sports. It's the only thing people care about today. It looks like they only care about sports.

Mhm.

The institutional risk transfer and hedging opportunity for prediction markets is 10 times larger than sports and there is no incumbent

Yeah.

because everybody is is pushed and pulled in every single direction. The risk transfer market is something that hasn't evolved in decades frankly, right? You have interest rate swaps, you have credit default swaps. You know, in two Fed meetings ago, the prediction market was pricing the probability of a cut 15% cheaper than the implied probability of an interest rate swap. Like excuse like I can knock on my microphone, but excuse me, like where is this spread coming from?

You know, why are you selling institutions such a large spread? Prediction markets are better. The price discovery is better. The information is valuable. Um but not only that, if we're talking about credit default swap, there's no credit default swap for private companies.

Just imagine, Anthropic, OpenAI, no credit default swap. Trillions of dollars in assets under management, you cannot buy a credit default swap on a private company. And so, we're approaching from first principles, how do we use prediction markets and other kinds of structured financial products to bring risk transfer into the fintech generation, into the the modern world, and how do we solve problems for our customers, for institutions, and for enterprises, so they can cover really important and critical tail risks in their portfolio.

Does anyone have a reaction to that? Cuz I I think it's a very important point that and we'll talk about this in a second. You know, there's a lot of focus on sports. I think it was Was it Tarik earlier who said, well, sports may have been 90% a couple of months ago the revenue, but now it's 60%. And I think that's a direction we're going to continue to see, regardless of what happens with litigation.

Um how are people thinking about that? Where Where will the data be most useful? People have mentioned uh interest rates, people have mentioned polling. Let me ask you this way, is there an area that people are not focusing on enough where prediction market data can really be useful?

Let me Let me take a first stab at it.

Yeah.

That's all right. I I mean, I think you know, we heard Tarik this morning talk about kind of the hive mind and how that's adding efficiencies to risk that people haven't or institutions haven't thought much about. Um I think to CJ's point, one of the one of the amazing things about event contracts and prediction markets is that they are really a blank canvas to be able to build risk management products on top of that have gone outside of the box of what has been traditionally offered by large institutions and I think there's a there is a chicken in the egg. I think you know, what one of the things I was hearing Tariq saying was that you know, the push into some new markets has really brought in more liquidity, more traders, more market makers to make some of these other markets or these other kinds of products more liquid. And I mean, there's been a product on Kalshi for the last, you know, year that I was following really closely to CJ's point around uh you know, the Fed about how many interest rate cuts there would be this year.

And at the beginning of the year, zero interest rate cuts was trading at 6%. And now I think it's trading at 90%. And all of us, to some degree, maybe to a large degree, are exposed to interest rate price movements, either for different mortgages or debt that we have, right? Imagine if you had a large purchase that was going to be debt-funded and you wanted to hedge the um the lack of an interest rate cut this year by getting into that contract, you would very simply have been able to take a position that resulted in a 12 or 13 X

Yeah.

uh payoff in 9 months. Right? Otherwise, you'd have to go and use some very complicated, you know, option strategy through a Wall Street firm and who knows even what you'd get paid out at, right? So, the landscape is fantastic. The more liquidity that comes in through a variety of markets, I think the better off a lot of the other markets will be and it's just an exciting time for these kinds of products.

But I

So, I wanted to just pick up on that a little bit, which is to say that these markets have enormous potential for leveraging these three things that we're seeing here, which is one, enormous amounts of retail attention, speaking to JB's point, um being able to then bring that into helping financial institutions and others hedge their risks, and number three, hopefully providing a public good in the form of information. Now, there's one area in which I think that can really be leveraged, and that's in relation to climate science and climate change. And having markets, prediction markets that are able to think about forecasting some of those outcomes. Now, at Unbundl, I can just, you know, pitch a little bit, we tried to build a climate change prediction market, right? Like which was designed specifically to get the public engaged.

Everyone here has an opinion. Everyone here, you know, can absorb that information. Everyone can think about what can be a probability, and helping institutions hedge their risk using some of that information to be able to capture some of the climate change risk in their products, in their lending products, and some of their supply chain dynamics, and others that they're trying to think about. And finally, ultimately, this is a public good, right? Being able to use information as a way to inform, as a way to help people, you know, think about what's coming ahead of them.

That is the ultimate good that these markets have the promise to provide, and have done since the '60s, which is creating information ecosystem that everyone can use in a productive way.

So, Gabe, I guess I just to add a little bit here, I think what's interesting about it is people forget this is a 24-month-old

Right.

marketplace. Like when we first started, we were doing election contracts, and we were talking about how could this actually transform anywhere, and then it moved into sports, and then it moved into financial products, moved into price volatility. What you're actually you're seeing is sort of this unique phenomenon in my mind, where it's an evolution and a revolution occurring simultaneously. So, I think as you ask, you know, why are sports there? I think that was one of the first markets that were clearly inefficient.

Yep.

Right? Elections and politics and polling, inefficient marketplace. Now all of a sudden you're starting to see it develop out closer and closer. And I think, you know, just as you talk about some of these financial products, just just think about the jobs report, the non-farm payroll, right? Occurs basically first Friday of every month.

If you are a trader, I don't care if you are a retail trader, a fund trader, an institutional trader that's out there, how do you hedge your portfolio? You basically have to go out and either buy you have to put it in there an options contract, you have to do a futures contract. You're basically creating what I call as a correlated trade. Prediction markets is actually allow you to take your risk down to the lowest level. I think it's going to be there it'll be a beat by 10,000, 50,000, 100, whatever it may be.

It actually allows you to really zero in your risk and be so precise that that becomes something that we haven't had before. So I think the minute you are able to take that precision and put it out to the general marketplace, that's what actually I think is scary about it is cuz people haven't seen this before and that's why I say there's this revolution and evolution that's occurring. So sports was the first, now we're working into financials and I think you'll see continue to see that evolve over the near future.

I thought you'd jump in.

I do think though it's important note and I think JB made this point you this this all sort of started with retail and now we obviously see the institutional marketplace using the data. I think for the institutional marketplace to start trading and to build liquidity it that doesn't happen overnight.

And as much as the this market has has obviously transformed quite quickly, one of the things that we obviously spend a lot of time with given our institutional marketplace and with interest rate swaps and rates products is how can you build liquidity for the institutional marketplace from the what is started as a retail base. And that doesn't happen overnight, you need you need clarity on rules, you need clarity on market structure, um and you also need balance sheet being applied to these, whether they're binary contracts or, you know, as opposed to a specific prediction market trade. And those are the types of things that we're very focused on because we think that there's there's a lot to do there. Um but we have enough experience to know that that just doesn't happen at the flip of a switch. And so you you have to build the trust in the and the liquidity over time.

I I think that that's not going to be an overnight thing.

So, it's not a prediction market panel without talking about the ongoing uh litigation and and circuit splits and the like. So, let's assume this is going to go to the Supreme Court and let's assume we're not going to have a resolution on it for people who would know better than I am, you know, at least a couple months, probably a year. How does that affect the use of this data? Right? So, if you have a stream of data and that data may or may not be used in a continuous basis, may not be able to be.

And maybe the answer is you just, you know, sports is a different thing. How do you think about building out systems to use that data with the lack of clarity around what will happen later on?

So, maybe I'll just get started cuz I have a bit of a doomer perspective in all of this right now because, you know, the the the let's I mean I the probability of the Supreme Court taking it, I think we don't need a prediction market contract on that is 100% like it really feels like this is going to happen. But even if the Supreme Court, let's say, you know, for argument's sake, sides with the prediction market platforms and says that the swaps are in fact fed, you know, that the contracts are in fact federal, that doesn't change anything right now, right? Because one can have now agency regulation that can get overturned by administrations following Loab per bright decisions, Trump versus Slaughter and others. And so one really needs to have congressional action at some stage in order to be able to develop some kind of resilient ecosystem around it from a legislative standpoint. And given what we saw with clarity, that is extremely hard if not near impossible to get.

So, when it comes to creating all of this incredible infrastructure that we're discussing here for financial institutions and others, what they need to see is not just regulatory clarity, but the ability for this ecosystem to grow in a sophisticated way based on a legislative and regulatory sense of permanence. And that, even if the Supreme Court says, "Hey, the platforms win." That's not clear even then that it's going to happen.

Yeah, can I I just pick up on that? I think it's a very interesting point um about the the Supreme Court aside or if the status quo stays the way it is, the potential for a future agency to overturn what the status quo is right now. Um I I take the other side of that. I think the law

market, you'll take the other side?

say I would say yeah, I take the other side. Here or if I'm not allowed to, but yeah, yeah, I would. Because and I try I tried to spend a lot of time with this, and I think this is what actually what led Kalshi to successfully challenge the CFTC's determination that elections contracts were contrary to the public interest because they said elections have no economic or financial or commercial consequence, and they said it's gambling. Both of those things are wrong. Elections have huge financial, commercial, economic consequence, and elections are not games.

They are elections. Regardless of whether or not you want them to be banned, the law does not allow them to be banned. And I think the law is written in a way, in my view, in a very positive way, to limit the value judgments that regulators or any regulator or any person can make around the {quote} {unquote} appropriateness or economic sufficiency or utility of any given contract because it recognizes that events are discreet, do pose risks, which means a valuable and viable legal derivative can be listed upon those. So, is there flexibility a future CFTC might try to find in the statute to make value judgments? Sure, but in my mind that's just going to lead to more litigation that will ultimately go against the agency.

Okay, 20 seconds. So, let's do a really quick wrap. If you want to talk about a fire round. Um one sentence, it's 10 years from now, 2036, we're on this stage. What do you want to see prediction markets having done over the last 10 years?

What do you not want to see in the prediction market space over the last 10 years?

It'd be um I would love to see it the conversation be less about sports and more about the evolution and of financial products and how it's been expanded out to customers both domestically and globally. The thing I don't want to see is the continued differences in regulatory oversight and discussion and clarity. It has to get cleared up or you're going to turn into crypto 2.0 where people are going to be going in many different directions with no real lead of where we should end up. CJ?

Well, I I mean I think in 10 years we might have prediction markets running on quantum computers generating the the future. Or two years from now. Yeah. However, um I hope that the regulatory climate in the US will continue to be friendly towards innovation in the derivatives and financial sector because I do believe that markets um accelerate a lot of good in the world. Um and I also hope that other regulators globally will follow suit.

Um and I I would certainly love more thoughtful kind of conversation around what is hedging in sports? Because is NFL Sunday really something that you need to hedge? Or is more like a directional index product better suited for the annual performance of a team, for example.

Doug, your turn.

I think we'll see an institutional marketplace and I hope it has uh both deep liquidity with integrity and proper market structure and and clear lines clear rules of engagement.

Ryan.

Yeah, I I couldn't agree more with that. What What I just hope is that um prediction market probabilities are embedded directly in news stories on all kinds of topics so that readers and consumers of information can judge what they are reading from an author matches or doesn't match what the market is saying about the importance or outcome of a particular event. What I don't want to see are jurisdictions continuing to take an approach of banning things in the name of customer protection as opposed to actually protecting customers.

Rachel, last word.

I'll be super quick. Um awesome governance, access to folks, and what I don't want to see is people feeling like it's rigged against them. The end.

So with that, thank you to the panelists. Thank you, everyone, and

Automatic transcript — names and jargon may be misspelled.